Sierra Club Ventana Chapterback issues
Explore, Enjoy and Protect the Planet  
Old Baldy, Canada | photo by Cameron Schaus

Sierra Club
Governor Davis signs legislation to save the Coastal Commission
by Bill Allayaud, State Legislative Director, Sierra Club California


On February 20, 2003 Governor Gray Davis signed legislation that will hopefully resolve the constitutional issue raised by the composition of the California Coastal Commission.

This legislative response was needed in the face of an adverse Court of Appeals ruling of December 30, 2002 in the Marine Forests vs. Coastal Commission case. The Marine Forests case involves a man in the Los Angeles area who has illegally dumped old tires and other objects in the ocean just offshore. His claim is that he is doing an experiment to show that habitat can be created from these materials. However, he failed to comply with various state laws including the Coastal Act that requires he receive a permit from the Coastal Commission for such a project.

The resulting lawsuit challenged the legality of the Coastal Commission itself and resulted ultimately in the new legislation signed by Governor Davis in February.

So for now, this issue is put to rest. But be assured that the conservative legal foundation that handled the case will pursue this matter as they would like nothing better than having no Coastal Commission around. The Sierra Club and other environmental organizations are equally committed to preserving the California coast. Stay tuned for the rest of the story.
[an error occurred while processing this directive]